| |
|
|
|
Alcohol Has No Food Value
Alcohol has no food value and is exceedingly limited in
its action as a remedial agent. Dr. Henry Monroe says, "every
kind of substance employed by man as food consists of sugar,
starch, oil and glutinous matter mingled together in various
proportions. These are designed for the support of the animal
frame. The glutinous principles of food fibrine, albumen and
casein are employed to build up the structure while the oil,
starch and sugar are chiefly used to generate heat in the
body".
Now it is clear that if alcohol is a food, it will be found to
contain one or more of these substances. There must be in it
either the nitrogenous elements found chiefly in meats, eggs,
milk, vegetables and seeds, out of which animal tissue is built
and waste repaired or the carbonaceous elements found in fat,
starch and sugar, in the consumption of which heat and force
are evolved.
"The distinctness of these groups of foods," says Dr. Hunt,
"and their relations to the tissue-producing and heat-evolving
capacities of man, are so definite and so confirmed by
experiments on animals and by manifold tests of scientific,
physiological and clinical experience, that no attempt to
discard the classification has prevailed. To draw so straight a
line of demarcation as to limit the one entirely to tissue or
cell production and the other to heat and force production
through ordinary combustion and to deny any power of
interchangeability under special demands or amid defective
supply of one variety is, indeed, untenable. This does not in
the least invalidate the fact that we are able to use these as
ascertained landmarks".
How these substances when taken into the body, are assimilated
and how they generate force, are well known to the chemist and
physiologist, who is able, in the light of well-ascertained
laws, to determine whether alcohol does or does not possess a
food value. For years, the ablest men in the medical profession
have given this subject the most careful study, and have
subjected alcohol to every known test and experiment, and the
result is that it has been, by common consent, excluded from
the class of tissue-building foods. "We have never," says Dr.
Hunt, "seen but a single suggestion that it could so act, and
this a promiscuous guess. One writer (Hammond) thinks it
possible that it may 'somehow' enter into combination with the
products of decay in tissues, and 'under certain circumstances
might yield their nitrogen to the construction of new tissues.'
No parallel in organic chemistry, nor any evidence in animal
chemistry, can be found to surround this guess with the areola
of a possible hypothesis".
Dr. Richardson says: "Alcohol contains no nitrogen; it has none
of the qualities of structure-building foods; it is incapable
of being transformed into any of them; it is, therefore, not a
food in any sense of its being a constructive agent in building
up the body." Dr. W.B. Carpenter says: "Alcohol cannot supply
anything which is essential to the true nutrition of the
tissues." Dr. Liebig says: "Beer, wine, spirits, etc., furnish
no element capable of entering into the composition of the
blood, muscular fibre, or any part which is the seat of the
principle of life." Dr. Hammond, in his Tribune Lectures, in
which he advocates the use of alcohol in certain cases, says:
"It is not demonstrable that alcohol undergoes conversion into
tissue." Cameron, in his Manuel of Hygiene, says: "There is
nothing in alcohol with which any part of the body can be
nourished." Dr. E. Smith, F.R.S., says: "Alcohol is not a true
food. It interferes with alimentation." Dr. T.K. Chambers says:
"It is clear that we must cease to regard alcohol, as in any
sense, a food".
"Not detecting in this substance," says Dr. Hunt, "any
tissue-making ingredients, nor in its breaking up any
combinations, such as we are able to trace in the cell foods,
nor any evidence either in the experience of physiologists or
the trials of alimentarians, it is not wonderful that in it we
should find neither the expectancy nor the realization of
constructive power."
Not finding in alcohol anything out of which the body can be
built up or its waste supplied, it is next to be examined as to
its heat-producing quality.
Production of heat.
------------------
"The first usual test for a force-producing food," says Dr.
Hunt, "and that to which other foods of that class respond, is
the production of heat in the combination of oxygen therewith.
This heat means vital force, and is, in no small degree, a
measure of the comparative value of the so-called respiratory
foods. If we examine the fats, the starches and the sugars, we
can trace and estimate the processes by which they evolve heat
and are changed into vital force, and can weigh the capacities
of different foods. We find that the consumption of carbon by
union with oxygen is the law, that heat is the product, and
that the legitimate result is force, while the result of the
union of the hydrogen of the foods with oxygen is water. If
alcohol comes at all under this class of foods, we rightly
expect to find some of the evidences which attach to the
hydrocarbons."
What, then, is the result of experiments in this direction?
They have been conducted through long periods and with the
greatest care, by men of the highest attainments in chemistry
and physiology, and the result is given in these few words, by
Dr. H.R. Wood, Jr., in his Materia Medica. "No one has been
able to detect in the blood any of the ordinary results of its
oxidation." That is, no one has been able to find that alcohol
has undergone combustion, like fat, or starch, or sugar, and so
given heat to the body.
Alcohol and reduction of temperature.
------------------------------------
instead of increasing it; and it has even been used in fevers
as an anti-pyretic. So uniform has been the testimony of
physicians in Europe and America as to the cooling effects of
alcohol, that Dr. Wood says, in his Materia Medica, "that it
does not seem worth while to occupy space with a discussion of
the subject." Liebermeister, one of the most learned
contributors to Zeimssen's Cyclopaedia of the Practice of
Medicine, 1875, says: "I long since convinced myself, by direct
experiments, that alcohol, even in comparatively large doses,
does not elevate the temperature of the body in either well or
sick people." So well had this become known to Arctic voyagers,
that, even before physiologists had demonstrated the fact that
alcohol reduced, instead of increasing, the temperature of the
body, they had learned that spirits lessened their power to
withstand extreme cold. "In the Northern regions," says Edward
Smith, "it was proved that the entire exclusion of spirits was
necessary, in order to retain heat under these unfavorable
conditions."
Alcohol does not make you strong.
--------------------------------
If alcohol does not contain tissue-building material, nor give
heat to the body, it cannot possibly add to its strength.
"Every kind of power an animal can generate," says Dr. G. Budd,
F.R.S., "the mechanical power of the muscles, the chemical (or
digestive) power of the stomach, the intellectual power of the
brain accumulates through the nutrition of the organ on which
it depends." Dr. F.R. Lees, of Edinburgh, after discussing the
question, and educing evidence, remarks: "From the very nature
of things, it will now be seen how impossible it is that
alcohol can be strengthening food of either kind. Since it
cannot become a part of the body, it cannot consequently
contribute to its cohesive, organic strength, or fixed power;
and, since it comes out of the body just as it went in, it
cannot, by its decomposition, generate heat force."
Sir Benjamin Brodie says: "Stimulants do not create nervous
power; they merely enable you, as it were, to use up that which
is left, and then they leave you more in need of rest than
before."
Baron Liebig, so far back as 1843, in his "Animal Chemistry,"
pointed out the fallacy of alcohol generating power. He says:
"The circulation will appear accelerated at the expense of the
force available for voluntary motion, but without the
production of a greater amount of mechanical force." In his
later "Letters," he again says: "Wine is quite superfluous to
man, it is constantly followed by the expenditure of power"
whereas, the real function of food is to give power. He adds:
"These drinks promote the change of matter in the body, and
are, consequently, attended by an inward loss of power, which
ceases to be productive, because it is not employed in
overcoming outward difficulties i.e., in working." In other
words, this great chemist asserts that alcohol abstracts the
power of the system from doing useful work in the field or
workshop, in order to cleanse the house from the defilement of
alcohol itself.
The late Dr. W. Brinton, Physician to St. Thomas', in his great
work on Dietetics, says: "Careful observation leaves little
doubt that a moderate dose of beer or wine would, in most
cases, at once diminish the maximum weight which a healthy
person could lift. Mental acuteness, accuracy of perception and
delicacy of the senses are all so far opposed by alcohol, as
that the maximum efforts of each are incompatible with the
ingestion of any moderate quantity of fermented liquid. A
single glass will often suffice to take the edge off both mind
and body, and to reduce their capacity to something below their
perfection of work."
Dr. F.R. Lees, F.S.A., writing on the subject of alcohol as a
food, makes the following quotation from an essay on
"Stimulating Drinks," published by Dr. H.R. Madden, as long ago
as 1847: "Alcohol is not the natural stimulus to any of our
organs, and hence, functions performed in consequence of its
application, tend to debilitate the organ acted upon.
Alcohol is incapable of being assimilated or converted into any
organic proximate principle, and hence, cannot be considered
nutritious.
The strength experienced after the use of alcohol is not new
strength added to the system, but is manifested by calling into
exercise the nervous energy pre-existing.
The ultimate exhausting effects of alcohol, owing to its
stimulant properties, produce an unnatural susceptibility to
morbid action in all the organs, and this, with the plethora
superinduced, becomes a fertile source of disease.
A person who habitually exerts himself to such an extent as to
require the daily use of stimulants to ward off exhaustion, may
be compared to a machine working under high pressure. He will
become much more obnoxious to the causes of disease, and will
certainly break down sooner than he would have done under more
favorable circumstances.
The more frequently alcohol is had recourse to for the purpose
of overcoming feelings of debility, the more it will be
required, and by constant repetition a period is at length
reached when it cannot be foregone, unless reaction is
simultaneously brought about by a temporary total change of the
habits of life.
Driven to the wall.
------------------
Not finding that alcohol possesses any direct alimentary value,
the medical advocates of its use have been driven to the
assumption that it is a kind of secondary food, in that it has
the power to delay the metamorphosis of tissue. "By the
metamorphosis of tissue is meant," says Dr. Hunt, "that change
which is constantly going on in the system which involves a
constant disintegration of material; a breaking up and avoiding
of that which is no longer aliment, making room for that new
supply which is to sustain life." Another medical writer, in
referring to this metamorphosis, says: "The importance of this
process to the maintenance of life is readily shown by the
injurious effects which follow upon its disturbance. If the
discharge of the excrementitious substances be in any way
impeded or suspended, these substances accumulate either in the
blood or tissues, or both. In consequence of this retention and
accumulation they become poisonous, and rapidly produce a
derangement of the vital functions. Their influence is
principally exerted upon the nervous system, through which they
produce most frequent irritability, disturbance of the special
senses, delirium, insensibility, coma, and finally, death."
"This description," remarks Dr. Hunt, "seems almost intended
for alcohol." He then says: "To claim alcohol as a food because
it delays the metamorphosis of tissue, is to claim that it in
some way suspends the normal conduct of the laws of
assimilation and nutrition, of waste and repair. A leading
advocate of alcohol (Hammond) thus illustrates it: 'Alcohol
retards the destruction of the tissues. By this destruction,
force is generated, muscles contract, thoughts are developed,
organs secrete and excrete.' In other words, alcohol interferes
with all these. No wonder the author 'is not clear' how it does
this, and we are not clear how such delayed metamorphosis
recuperates.
Not an originator of vital force.
--------------------------------
which is not known to have any of the usual power of foods, and
use it on the double assumption that it delays metamorphosis of
tissue, and that such delay is conservative of health, is to
pass outside of the bounds of science into the land of remote
possibilities, and confer the title of adjuster upon an agent
whose agency is itself doubtful.
Having failed to identify alcohol as a nitrogenous or
non-nitrogenous food, not having found it amenable to any of
the evidences by which the food-force of aliments is generally
measured, it will not do for us to talk of benefit by delay of
regressive metamorphosis unless such process is accompanied
with something evidential of the fact something scientifically
descriptive of its mode of accomplishment in the case at hand,
and unless it is shown to be practically desirable for
alimentation.
There can be no doubt that alcohol does cause defects in the
processes of elimination which are natural to the healthy body
and which even in disease are often conservative of health.
by -
Back
to Top
###
| |
|
|
Snowboard
Addiction snowboard addiction Is The Worlds Best
Online Snowboard Coaching! Video Lessons, Podcasts To Ride With
And Manuals With Photos And Diagrams. It Incorporates Both A
Freestyle Program And A Learn To Snowboard
Program.
Click Here for More
Info!>>
101 Secrets Of A
Microsoft Excel Addict. You Are About To Discover 101 Of Excels
Little-known Secrets That Have Been Hiding Right Under Your
Nose. These Secrets Are Guaranteed To Boost Your Excel Skills
And Productivity Far Ahead Of Everyone Around You. Imagine! You
The Excel
Expert!
Click Here for More
Info!>>
End Your Internet
Sex Site Addiction. An Easy To Read Book On Resolving An Addiction
To X-rated Movies And Pictures. Written By A Psychology
Graduate And Includes Bonus Video
Program. Click Here for More
Info!>>
Addiction Free Forever Program. A
Complete At-home Addiction Recovery Program That Permanently
And Naturally Cures An Alcohol Or Drug
Addiction. Click Here for More
Info!>>
Cannabis Addicts
Self Help Stop Smoking. Self Help EBook(R) For
Cannabis Users. Stop Smoking Cannabis For Good!
Guaranteed. Click Here for More
Info!>>
Alcoholism & Drug Addiction Recovery
Workbook. Alcoholism And Drug Addiction Is Not A
Disease But A Choice! This Workbook Is For Those Who Struggle
With 'recovery' And Just Cant Find The Answers They Seek In Aa,
Na Or Current Treatment Programs. Practical & Empowering
Self-help Recovery
Information. Click Here for More
Info!>>
Trading Addicts
Subscription. Follow Along With Top Traders As They
Profit In Stocks, Options, Futures, And Forex Markets In
Real-time. Click Here for More
Info!>>
Secrets Of Sexual
Addiction. Would You Like To Have The Best Sex
Life Possible? Bold, New Information That Will Change Your Sex
Life Forever! Click Here for More
Info!>>
Alternative Health Center
- Overcoming
Drug Addictions, Quit Smoking. Overcoming Drug Addictions
Multi-media Product, Quit Smoking, Arthritis Relief, Prostate
Health, Lowering Cholesterol And Other Information Products.
Learn The Latest Cutting Edge Information From Experts In The
Alternative Health
Field.
Click Here for More
Info!>>
Overcome Your Nasal Spray
Addiction. EBook Detailing How To Overcome A
(rhinitis Medicamentosa) Nasal Spray Addiction...a Condition
Suffered By 10 Million
Americans,. Click Here for More
Info!>>
|